The Band - The Last Waltz (The Complete Last Waltz) (4 CD Box Set) (1978)

Review by Bill Glahn
This review first appeared in the November '95 Live! Music Review, a monthly publication providing quality reviews of the latest bootleg releases and more. Reproduced with permission from the author. See also Jonathan Katz' article on the different versions of the Last Waltz.

A complete soundboard or film source is used for this elaborate four-CD set presenting The Band's farewell show from Thanksgiving Day 1976 at the Winterland in San Francisco. The concert was filmed by Martin Scorsese and a three-LP soundtrack was released with some songs eliminated and the sequence of performances shuffled around to give a better flow. The Complete Last Waltz collects all the omitted tracks and is sequenced exactly as the concert was played. The CDs packaging is just as exquisite as the original event. The four discs are contained in a book binder cover housing the CD "envelopes" as well as a copy of the Last Waltz guest welcome card. Also included are 36 pages of photos, liner notes, song and personnel listings, discographies and the like. Each binder is numbered and only 3,000 sets were pressed. The recording is a solid one. It's an unmixed soundboard, so even the released tracks have a slightly different flavour to them. Some portions contain a "hum" indicating that this might be from film footage but it doesn't intrude too badly. The Complete Last Waltz is for those of you who just couldn't be satisfied with a chopped version of The Band's last show.

Here are the 17 tracks omitted from the official Capitol release:

1. This Wheel's on Fire
Co-written with Dylan and found on Music From Big Pink, this version gets a deluxe orchestra and horn arrangement by Allen Toussaint.

2. The W.S. Walcott Medicine Show
From Stage Fright, Toussaint also arranges the horns to give this a better effect.

3. Georgia on My Mind MPEG3-file (4.8 MB)
No one can draw on their own personal sadness when singing a melancholy number better than Richard Manuel. The omission of this track from the official release is unpardonable.

4. King Harvest
Another favourite sadly left off The Last Waltz.

5. Rag Mama Rag
Dixieland seems to be the theme here. This is a radical departure from the studio version with Howard Johnson leading a horn section of clarinets and tubas with a good measure of honky tonk piano thrown in for good measure. Listed with Robbie Robertson as singer, but it sure sounds like Levon Helm to me.

6. Caledonia
Not many realise that this number is a Louis Jordan cover. Muddy Waters gets the call to do the lead vocal. Paul Butterfield adds some great harp playing to this version but isn't listed.

7. All Our Past Times
Eric Clapton entered the proceedings with this number from his No Reason To Cry album and splits the lead vocal with Rick Danko.

8. Four Strong Winds
Neil Young covers this Ian Tyson song. It's more interesting than "Helpless" which made the official album.

9. Shadows & Light
Joni Mitchell may be a great songwriter but she's not a terribly strong performer. Left off the album with good reason.

10. Furry Sings the Blues
Joni Mitchell again.

11. Acadian Driftwood
A strong version with help from Neil Young and Joni Mitchell.

12. Chest Fever
Although this track was always a concert highlight, it just doesn't work here. The heavy focus on horns instead of Robertson's guitar takes all the guts out of it. The Band also seems uncomfortable with the arrangement. With these factors and its 12-min length, I can understand why it was excluded.

13. Hazel
Bob Dylan gives a simplistic reading of this cut from Planet Waves.

14. I Shall Be Released
Dylan and Richard Manuel share the vocals.

15. Instrumental Jam #1
This 12-min jam starts off with a drum duel between Ringo and Levon Helm before turning into a boogie-style guitar showcase with Ron Wood, Clapton, Young, Stephen Stills and Robertson.

16. Instrumental Jam #2 AU file (292K)
This is a slow blues featuring Garth Hudson's keyboards and lasting over 17 mins.

17. Don't Do It
The closing song of the show and an unforgivable exclusion from the official release for that reason alone. A set meant to close out a band's career should have contained their final notes.

The Complete Last Waltz is a pricey affair but with such a large dose of worthwhile unreleased material, it is well worth the investment to those with more than a passing appreciation for The Band.

Wikipedia:

The Last Waltz was a concert by the Canadian-American rock group, The Band, held on Thanksgiving Day, November 25, 1976, at Winterland Ballroom in San Francisco. Billed as a "farewell" performance after 16 years of touring, the concert saw The Band joined by more than a dozen special guests, including Paul Butterfield, Eric Clapton, Neil Diamond, Bob Dylan, Ronnie Hawkins, Dr. John, Joni Mitchell, Van Morrison, Ringo Starr, Muddy Waters, Ronnie Wood and Neil Young.

The event was filmed by director Martin Scorsese and made into a documentary of the same name, released in 1978. The film features concert performances, scenes shot on a studio soundstage and interviews by Scorsese with members of The Band. A triple-LP soundtrack recording was issued in 1978. The film was released on DVD in 2002 as was a four-CD box set of the concert and related studio recordings.

The Last Waltz is hailed as one of the greatest concert films ever made.

Origins

The idea for a farewell concert came about early in 1976 after Richard Manuel was seriously injured in a boating accident. Robbie Robertson then began giving thought to leaving the road, envisioning The Band becoming a studio-only band, similar to The Beatles' decision to stop playing live shows in 1966.

Though the other band members did not agree with Robertson's decision, the concert was set at Bill Graham's Winterland Ballroom, where The Band had made its debut as a group in 1969.Originally, The Band was to perform on its own, but then the notion of inviting Ronnie Hawkins and Bob Dylan was hatched and the guest list grew to include other performers.




The Band was a Canadian-American rock group, active from 1967 to 1976 and again from 1983 to 1999. It mainly consisted of Canadians Robbie Robertson (guitar, piano); Richard Manuel (piano, harmonica, drums, saxophone, organ); Garth Hudson (organ, piano, clavinet, accordion, synthesizer, saxophone); Rick Danko (bass guitar, violin, trombone), and an American Levon Helm (drums, mandolin, guitar, bass guitar).

The members of the Band first worked together as The Hawks, the backing band of rockabilly singer Ronnie Hawkins from 1959 until 1963; they were also known as Levon and the Hawks. (In about 1966, they released a single on Ware Records under the name the Canadian Squires). Afterwards, Bob Dylan recruited the group for his 1965-1966 world tour. They also joined him on the informal recordings that later became The Basement Tapes.

Dubbed "The Band" by their record company (a name derived from how they were referred to during their tenure with Dylan), the group left Saugerties, New York to begin recording their own material. They recorded two of the most acclaimed albums of the late 1960s; their 1968 debut Music from Big Pink (featuring the single "The Weight") and 1969's The Band. They broke up in 1976, but reformed in 1983 without founding guitarist Robbie Robertson.

Although the Band was always more popular with music journalists and fellow musicians than with the general public, they have remained an admired and influential group. They have been inducted into the Canadian Music Hall of Fame and the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. In 2004, Rolling Stone ranked them #50 on their list of the 100 Greatest Artists of All Time.

Tracklists:

CD 1

01 - Theme From The Last Waltz
02 - Up On Cripple Creek
03 - The Shape I'm In
04 - It Makes No Difference
05 - Who Do You Love (With Ronnie Hawkins)
06 - Life Is A Carnival
07 - Such A Night (With Dr John)
08 - The Weight
09 - Down South In New Orleans (With Bobby Charles)
10 - This Wheel's On Fire
11 - Mystery Train (With Paul Butterfield)
12 - Caldonia (With Muddy Waters)
13 - Mannish Boy (With Muddy Waters)
14 - Stage Fright

CD 2

01 - Rag Mama Rag
02 - All Our Past Times (With Eric Clapton)
03 - Further On Up The Road (With Eric Clapton)
04 - Ophelia
05 - Helpless (With Neil Young)
06 - Four Strong Winds (With Neil Young)
07 - Coyote (With Joni Mitchell)
08 - Shadows And Light (With Joni Mitchell)
09 - Furry Sings The Blues (With Joni Mitchell)
10 - Arcadian Driftwood
11 - Dry Your Eyes (With Neil Diamond)
12 - The W.S. Walcott Medicine Show
13 - Tura Lura Lural (That's An Irish Lullaby) (With Van Morrison)
14 - Caravan (With Van Morrison)

CD 3

01 - The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down
02 - The Genetic Method
03 - Baby Let Me Follow You Down (With Bob Dylan)
04 - Hazel (With Bob Dylan)
05 - I Don't Believe You (With Bob Dylan)
06 - Forever Young (With Bob Dylan)
07 - Baby Let Me Follow You Down Reprise (With Bob Dylan)
08 - I Shall Be Released
09 - Jam #1
10 - Jam #2
11 - Don't Do It
12 - Greensleeves

CD 4

01 - The Well
02 - Evangeline (With Emmylou Harris)
03 - Out Of The Blue
04 - The Weight (With The Staples)
05 - The Last Waltz Refrain
06 - Theme From The Last Waltz
07 - King Harvest Has Surely Come
08 - Tura Lura Lural (Rehearsal With Van Morrison)
09 - Caravan (Rehearsal With Van Morrison)
10 - Such A Night (Rehearsal With Dr John)
11 - Rag Mama Rag (Studio Ideas)
12 - Mad Waltz (Studio Ideas)
13 - The Last Waltz Refrain (Studio Ideas Instrumental Version)
14 - The Last Waltz Theme (Studio Ideas Sketch)